Review: American Gods

Robby with Bird

Written By Robby

I'm currently serving as the discipleship pastor at North Pointe Church in Lutz, Florida. I have a master's degree in biblical interpretation. I love thinking about things from a theological perspective and considering the hard questions of life. I have an affinity for technology. I enjoy photography, backpacking, video games, and writing.

May 10, 2017

American Gods
American Gods by Neil Gaiman

My rating: 4 of 5 stars

This book was something else. I read about Neil Gaiman’s thoughts on how he wrote “American Gods.” He said that he was looking to write a story that was a little bit of a murder mystery, a road trip story, an adventure, and a mythological story. Boy did he ever. “American Gods” is always ready to surprise you. As I read I eventually started to anticipate when another curve ball was going to be thrown my way. I couldn’t always figure out the twist and turns before I got to them, but I definitly started to expect them. I thought this was fascinating. The way “American Gods” keeps you on the edge of you seat is extrodinary.

The characters are fascinating. Each one has their own already established mythos in the real world that Gaiman masterfully blends into his story. The ways they behave seem to make them feel like they actually originate from their respective home lands. Characters develop, but in subtle ways. I actually quite prefer the subtly. Characters don’t just shed their flaws as the story goes on, but actually evolve organically due to their experiences. The way America and the small towns “American Gods” visits in the book play into the overall story makes them feel like characters themselves.

Like I said earlier, American Gods feels like multiple stories wrapped into one. As Shadow and Wednesday move from location to location, their story changes and shifts as well. Story lines end and new ones begin multiple times throughout the book. This is never done in a way were the reader would be lost or confused. In fact, this gives the book a really high-energy pacing and tends to minimize any slow or tedious spots in the plot. The way that Gaiman weaves the stories together is really masterful. They always seem to end in a satisfactory manner before a new one starts to wind up.

Gaiman also does an amazing job giving his locations life. I’ve never personally traveled to the road side attractions and small towns that he describes, but they certainly felt believable to me. Each location also felt very different than the last. Gaiman has a way of placing the reader in the events of “American Gods” and in the locations all throughout America. Even the “Coming to America” asides littered throughout the book help give an over all feeling and mood to the plot and inform the reader about the deeper meanings and actions to the plot, and they help better characterize America as a location.

“American Gods” was simply a delight to read. If I was to explain the plot to a friend, I’m sure they would have a very difficult time understanding. Fortunately, Gaiman writes his story in a way that the reader can easily keep up. The complexities of the story are very easily understood and digested. I often find that books as ambitious as “American Gods” often end up making the reader spend more time trying to understand what is happening and less time actually enjoying the story. No such problem exists in “American Gods.” I will be a bit critical and say that at a few points the story was a bit nebulous and the explanations to events were not always obvious. This left me sometimes wondering why something was happening the way it was, but these instances were very few and far between. They certainly did not detract much from the overall story.

I think the best thing I can say about “American Gods” is that Gaiman has some how taken an entire nation that actually exists and that many are very familiar with and transformed it into a magical and mysterious place. It’s world building with the potential to be on the scale of the wizarding world shown in Harry Potter, but it still feels somehow very believable and very real. “American Gods” was a wonderful read that even though it has its confusing parts, still manages to entertain, mystify, and excite the reader.

View all my reviews

You May Also Like…

The Impact of VBS on Church Community

The Impact of VBS on Church Community

I’ll be honest—I used to be that pastor who rolled my eyes at VBS, convinced it was just glorified babysitting dressed up in Bible costumes. After spending years on the planning side of things, watching volunteers transform our worship center into a spaceship and witnessing high schoolers serve alongside grandparents, my perspective has completely shifted. It turns out that VBS isn’t just about teaching kids Bible stories for a week; it’s about showing them (and their parents) that they genuinely matter to our church community. When I watched our congregation of all ages come together to serve 80 kids for five nights straight, I realized VBS might just be the most powerful community-building program we have. Who knew that the ministry I once dismissed would become the very picture of multi-generational discipleship I’d been preaching about all along?

A Decade Together

A Decade Together

Ten years ago, I made a commitment to Samantha—to love her, serve her, and stick by her through all life’s ups and downs. A decade later, I’ve learned that marriage is far less about keeping score and far more about embracing humility, servanthood, and a shared commitment to growth. From navigating life’s inevitable challenges to choosing happiness over being right, each lesson has shaped the bond we share. This milestone isn’t just about celebrating where we’ve been; it’s about looking forward to all the lessons and laughter that lie ahead. Here’s to ten years with my incredible wife—and to many more.

It’s Been Real, Harmony

It’s Been Real, Harmony

Eight years ago, I joined Harmony Christian Church. Today, I leave an entirely different person. All things end. I’m grateful for all it all.

The Impact of VBS on Church Community

The Impact of VBS on Church Community

I’ll be honest—I used to be that pastor who rolled my eyes at VBS, convinced it was just glorified babysitting dressed up in Bible costumes. After spending years on the planning side of things, watching volunteers transform our worship center into a spaceship and witnessing high schoolers serve alongside grandparents, my perspective has completely shifted. It turns out that VBS isn’t just about teaching kids Bible stories for a week; it’s about showing them (and their parents) that they genuinely matter to our church community. When I watched our congregation of all ages come together to serve 80 kids for five nights straight, I realized VBS might just be the most powerful community-building program we have. Who knew that the ministry I once dismissed would become the very picture of multi-generational discipleship I’d been preaching about all along?

A Decade Together

A Decade Together

Ten years ago, I made a commitment to Samantha—to love her, serve her, and stick by her through all life’s ups and downs. A decade later, I’ve learned that marriage is far less about keeping score and far more about embracing humility, servanthood, and a shared commitment to growth. From navigating life’s inevitable challenges to choosing happiness over being right, each lesson has shaped the bond we share. This milestone isn’t just about celebrating where we’ve been; it’s about looking forward to all the lessons and laughter that lie ahead. Here’s to ten years with my incredible wife—and to many more.

0 Comments

Leave a Reply